We compared public evidence on September 26, 2026. We did not create accounts, buy plans or run paid conversations. Our recommendations identify a sensible first investigation for a reader’s task; they are not laboratory scores or guarantees of specialist rendering. The same eight criteria apply to all five named services.
Our Eight-Criterion Scorecard
| Criterion | Weight | What we assess |
|---|---|---|
| Persona controls | 25% | Distinct identity, voice and scene fields |
| Public access | 10% | Public interface and path to evaluation |
| Continuity | 15% | Evidence of stable identity and recalled events |
| Visual tools | 10% | Species identity through repeated outputs |
| Price clarity | 15% | Term and actual upfront commitment |
| Free limits | 10% | Measured access without a purchase |
| Content rules | 10% | Adult fictional use and stated boundaries |
| Evidence strength | 5% | Sources support the specific recommendation |
Weights express the importance of each criterion for an original persona. We do not calculate a performance total where evidence is missing. A future numeric score would use the same weights and show the underlying observations. In today’s matrix, documented, observed and unverified are evidence states rather than numbers.
What Would Earn An Eight Or A Five?
On a future ten-point scale, an eight requires specific attributable evidence that meets the intended task, with a known limitation. A five represents an identifiable claim or partial functionality without enough evidence of suitability. An unresolved identity receives no score. The following definitions show how each criterion would be assessed; they do not assign today’s subjects numerical ratings.
- Persona controls: eight — specific controls and examples documented; five — general customization claim only.
- Public access: eight — relevant interface directly observed; five — only inaccessible or ambiguous descriptions.
- Continuity: eight — dated repeatable session with observations; five — provider memory claim without session.
- Visual tools: eight — relevant original outputs checked; five — general gallery only.
- Price clarity: eight — captured term, collected amount and allowances; five — current total unverified.
- Free limits: eight — recorded limits and reset conditions; five — free signup label only.
- Content rules: eight — attributable current policy reviewed; five — unverified or unclear policy.
- Evidence strength: eight — public records plus reproducible observations; five — unresolved identity or generic claim.
Public Sources And Capture Limits
OurDreamAI: official public FAQ and the August 21 creator guide. CandyAI: a directly captured subscriptions panel and official anime-creation description. LoveScape: official customization and help descriptions plus live Premium, Creative PRO and Ultra billing lines. An earlier direct help challenge is separate from those readable plan pages. GoLove: public gallery, dedicated creator description, signed-out media form and privacy notice; account workflow remains unverified. Joi AI: prompt-led creator, anonymous USD subscription catalog and official terms; conflicting adult-policy wording remains a reader decision. GoLove prices are separately sourced from an official anonymous EUR catalog.
The reviews hub keeps those states comparable. Read the OurDreamAI review for the conditional creator recommendation, the CandyAI review for captured subscription terms and the LoveScape review for the help-access limitation. Our guides turn a small persona brief into a check you can evaluate without treating a promotional sample as your own result.
When We Say Compared Or Tested
Compared means we read and dated attributable public information. Observed means the relevant public interface was visible in a browser. A hands-on test would require a dated session, the account tier, the actual task and raw observations such as latency, usable output count or recall. We do not claim those sessions occurred. A picture of a feature description is evidence of the description, not successful use of the feature.